In a dramatic reversal, Disney has reinstated Jimmy Kimmel Live! after suspending the show amid controversy, backlash, and what appears to be a mass cancellation wave across its streaming services. Here’s what happened, why Disney flipped, and what the fallout could mean.
What Led to the Suspension
-
On September 17, 2025, Jimmy Kimmel Live! was temporarily suspended by Disney/ABC after host Jimmy Kimmel made critical remarks in his monologue about the assassination of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk.
-
The suspension came amid pressure from conservative media, protests from affiliates (Sinclair and Nexstar), and warnings from FCC Chair Brendan Carr about potential actions over what he considered “misinformation.”
-
In many markets, major ABC affiliates pulled the show from their lineups during the suspension.
The Backlash & Subscriber Losses
-
The suspension triggered a public uproar. Many accused Disney of yielding to political pressure and suppressing free speech.
-
Celebrities, unions (WGA, SAG-AFTRA), and industry voices rallied in defense of Kimmel, urging Disney to reverse the decision.
-
Most striking: between September 17–23, Disney reportedly lost 1.7 million streaming subscribers across Disney+, Hulu, and ESPN+.
-
Analysts noted that the “churn rate” during Kimmel’s suspension surged by more than 400% compared to prior weeks.
-
The timing of widespread cancellations coincided with a pending streaming price hike announcement, adding fuel to subscriber discontent.
Disney Reinstates Kimmel
-
Facing sharp financial and reputational pressure, Disney announced on September 22 that Jimmy Kimmel Live! would return to the airwaves on September 23.
-
Disney said the decision followed “thoughtful conversations” and that Kimmel would not be forced to compromise his editorial freedom.
-
Initially, many ABC affiliates under Sinclair and Nexstar pledged not to air the show upon its return.
-
But soon after, both Sinclair and Nexstar reversed course and announced they would resume carrying the show.
What Happened to Viewership & Ratings
-
Kimmel’s first show back drew high viewership—6.5 million viewers in some reports—in what many called a record spike for the show in recent years.
-
However, this surge was short-lived: by just a few days later, ratings dropped sharply (64% drop from the return night; demographic declines of 70%+) in key viewer groups (ages 18–49, 25–54).
-
The viewership volatility suggests that while many tuned in out of curiosity or protest, retaining that audience may be more challenging.
Why Disney Probably Reversed Course
-
Subscriber Damage & Financial Risk
With 1.7 million streaming cancellations in a week, the financial and reputational costs were high. Disney couldn’t afford mass defection in a competitive streaming landscape. P -
Talent & Industry Pressure
Disney risked alienating creators, entertainers, and industry unions who saw the move as censorship. Solidarity from writers, actors, and free-speech advocates put public pressure on the company. -
Regulatory & Political Pushback
The involvement of the FCC and threats over broadcast licenses made this a high-stakes conflict between media, politics, and regulation. Disney likely weighed the risks of standing firm—and losing. -
Public Relations & Brand Risk
The backlash over perceived suppression hit Disney’s family-friendly brand. Reinstituting Kimmel allowed Disney to appear responsive, rather than controlling.
What This Means Going Forward
-
Media Companies on Edge: This incident underscores how immediate public reaction (cancellations, social media) can force reversals—even from media giants.
-
Free Speech vs. Corporate Caution: Disney’s initial suspension and later reversal reflect the delicate balancing act between editorial freedom and political pressures in today’s polarized climate.
-
Subscriber Loyalty Is Fragile: In streaming wars, viewers vote with their wallets. A few decisions perceived as missteps can trigger cascading cancellations.
-
Wildcard Future Ratings: Kimmel’s return viewership was boosted by controversy, but sustaining consistent audiences will be the real test.
